Subject : ON EDWARD SAïD AND THE PALESTINIAN QUESTION: FROM THE CENTER FOR
THE ADVANCED STUDY OF AMERICAN INSTITUTIONS AND SOCIAL
MOVEMENTS,
6 October 2003
Dear Colleagues and Friends,
The death of
for the Advanced Study of American Institutions and Social Movements joins the
voices of lament and of renewed commitment in the spirit of Professor
Said, who never ceased to seek the truth in these dark days of deceit and disinformation.
. . . (For a complete list of articles on the life of Edward Saïd, please visit :
Below (item A.) is a memorial article on Professor Saïd by Phil Gasper, which was published in The Socialist Worker.
Next (item B.) is
an article by Gore Vidal, published as the Foreword to the late Israel Shahak's critical history of the Jewish people, Jewish
History,
Jewish Religion (Pluto Press, 3rd edition, 2002). Items C. and D. are Internet addresses which will
contribute to a greater understanding of the
relationships between Zionism, Anti-Semitism, and American foreign policy under
the Bush administration.
Finally, our student Ben Monange has sent us two articles from the New York Times that documents war
profiteering in war-torn
Bush administration. (Please visit our
Contracts in
Sincerely,
Francis McCollum Feeley
Professor of American Studies/
Director of Research
______________________
A.
From: http://www.socialistworker.org/2003-2/470/470_09_SaidObit.shtml
Paying tribute to Edward Said
by Phil Gasper
October 3, 2003
EDWARD SAID, the brilliant Palestinian
intellectual and activist, died last week at the age of 67 after a 12-year
battle against leukemia. He was a man of incredibly
broad learning and ability--a literary andcultural critic, a political writer, an opera lover who served as music editor of The Nation magazine, an accomplished
pianist, but above all the most eloquent and persuasive spokesperson for the
Palestinian people. It was this latter role that earned him, according to the
Al Jazeera news service, "public enemy number
one status among
Said was born in
British-occupied
and confiscated their property, Said began a life of permanent exile. In the 1950s,
he came to the
from the mid-1960s, eventually becoming a University Professor, the highest academic
position.
Books such as Joseph Conrad
and the Fiction of Autobiography and The World, the Text, and the Critic
established aid as one of the world's leading
literary theorists. He demonstrated that literature can only be understood in
the broader historical and social context in which it is written.
In one famous essay on
"Jane Austen and Empire," for example, he showed how
But Said refused to be an
armchair intellectual. He did not just theorize about the ideology of
imperialism, he became one of its most articulate
public opponents. In the 1970s, Said became the most prominent voice in the
The Israel-Palestinian conflict, he pointed out, "isn't a battle between
two states. It's a battle between a state [
attacking a colonized population, using all forms of collective
punishment."
Said argued the Palestinian
case with clarity and forcefulness in a stream of articles, opinion pieces and
books, including The Question of Palestine,
which remains the best short introduction to the whole issue. He also made hundreds
of appearances on college campuses. As a result, Said became a
major target of pro-Israel extremists. He and his family received numerous death
threats and his office at
But he refused to be
silenced. In 1977, he was appointed to the Palestine National Council (PNC), a
parliament-in-exile established by the Palestine
Liberation Organization (PLO). Said recognized the PLO as the Palestinian people's
only legitimate representative, but he grew increasingly critical of its
strategy and tactics, and of the autocratic style of its leader, Yasser Arafat.
Rather than futile appeals
to the major world powers and Arab governments for support, Said advocated an
international campaign against Israeli
repression, similar to the one that helped defeat South African apartheid. The
gap with the PLO's leadership widened after Said resigned
from the PNC in 1991. Two years later, when Arafat signed the
agreement's sharpest critic.
While the
surrender at the end of the First World War. At best,
portion of historic
time, it ignored the rights of Palestinian refugees outside the occupied
Said attacked the PA's corruption and abuses of power. The PLO leadership had
"become willing collaborators with the [Israeli] military
occupation."
Arafat was so outraged that he banned Said's books
from the Palestinian territories.
But Said was right that
wealthy Palestinians benefited from the deal, it offered nothing to ordinary
Palestinians, and it provided
In the 1980s, Said accepted
the PLO's call for a Palestinian state to exist side-by-side with
As the 1990s progressed,
Said also became a more outspoken critic of
the invasion and occupation of
It will be hard to come to
terms with the fact that Said's powerful voice is no
longer with us. But his enormous achievements will of course survive him,
and we can honor him best by continuing the struggles
to which he contributed so much.
_______________________
B.
From: Israel Shahak's Jewish History, Jewish Religion
Foreword by Gore Vidal
Sometime in the late 1950s,
that world-class gossip and occasional historian, John F. Kennedy, told me how,
in 1948, Harry S Truman had been
pretty much abandoned by everyone when he came to run for president. Then an American
Zionist brought him two million dollars in cash, in a suitcase,
aboard his whistle-stop campaign train. 'That's why our recognition of
Unfortunately, the hurried
recognition of Israel as a state has resulted in forty-five years of murderous
confusion, and the destruction of what Zionist
fellow travellers thought would be a pluralistic state - home to its native
population of Muslims, Christians and Jews, as well as a future home to
peaceful European and American Jewish immigrants, even the ones who affected to
believe that the great realtor in the sky had given them, in perpetuity, the
lands of Judea and Sameria. Since many of the
immigrants were good socialists in
Unlikely,
because no other minority in American history has ever hijacked so much money
from the American taxpayers in order to invest in a 'homeland'.
It is as if the American taxpayer had been obliged to support the Pope in his reconquest of the
In a sense, I rather admire
the way that the Israel lobby has gone about its business of seeing that
billions of dollars, year after year, go to make Israel a 'bulwark against
communism'. Actually, neither the
Fortunately, the voice of
reason is alive and well, and in
Needless to say,
1933 and spent his childhood in the concetration camp
at
the years when it was fashionable. He was - and still is -a humanist who
detests imperialism whether in the names of the God of Abraham or of George
Bush. Equally, he opposes with great wit and learning the totalitarian strain
in Judaism. Like a highly learned Thomas Paine, Shahak illustrates the prospect before us, as well as the long history behind us, and
thus he continues to reason, year after year. Those who heed him will certainly
be wiser and - dare I say? -better. He is the latest,
if not the last, of the great prophets.
_____________________________
C.
Israel Shahak
http://www.mepc.org/public_asp/journal_shahak/shahakmain.asp
______________________________
D.
http://www.codoh.com/zionweb/zionweb.html
******************
Francis McCollum Feeley
Professor of American Studies
Director of Research at CEIMSA
Center for the Advanced Study of American
Institutions and Social Movements
http://www.u-grenoble3.fr/ciesimsa
University of Grenoble-3
France
Tel: 04.76.82.43.00